Dyna Glo vs Char Broil: the Ultimate Cookdown

When it comes to grills, two famous names are Dyna-Glo and Char-Broil. These two grills have the best quality and value for money. You are probably caught up right now in the store aisle deciding which one to choose. Although you will not go wrong with either of the two, it’s still best to pick the one that will match your preferences and lifestyle.

The two have their set of unique features, pros, and cons. We have made the selection easy for you. We picked three grills each from the two brands. We paired them up according to the same category, so you will have a wise buying decision based on the features you like.

Three Comparisons

Based on the research, we can conclude that the Char Broil has superiority when it comes to the construction of the grills. The Char Broil compared with Dyna Glo, has more grill products available for sale, too.

1. Dyna-Glo DGE Series vs Char-Broil Performance 475


If you’re eyeing for liquid propane gas grill with four burners, your choices will be the Dyna-Glo DGE Series 4-Burner Grill and the Char-Broil Performance 475 4-Burner. However, they have different heat content in which the Dyna-Glo DGE Series is better.

Each of the four burners has 10,000 BTUs, not to mention the side burner with 12,000 BTUs. This grill delivers extreme heat that you need and is further improved by the stainless steel heat tents that vaporize and distribute the heat throughout the cooking surface.

The Char-Broil has lower BTU content and smaller cooking dimensions. Nonetheless, it can still accommodate family-size servings at a time. For added cooking area, you can swing the warming rack up for extra foods such as bread toasts and sides. It has metal side shelves too where you can place your utensils or food.

When it comes to electric ignition, both grills are exceptional. You can quickly start them up with just one push of a button.

Both grills come with a temperature gauge for accurate heat monitoring. Another similarity is the stainless steel construction of the burners, racks, and grates. However, the Dyna-Glo DGE Series 4 Burner Propane Grill has a dual-lid that traps heat tightly and dual-wall doors with locking casters for easy transport.

One advantage of the Char-Broil Performance 475 is the detachable grease pan that makes cleaning a breeze. You can wipe the surfaces with a damp cloth. It has a smaller built but without compromising the additional spaces for food preparation. An even smaller version of the 475 exists, which is the Char-Broil Performance 300. We picked that lighter, 2-burner grill to represent Char-Broil in its battle against Weber in one of our articles.

 Dyna-Glo DGE SeriesChar-Broil Performance 475
BTUs40,000 BTU36,000 BTU
Cooking area646 square inches475 square inches
Grease panYesYes, removable
Electronic ignitionYesYes
Warranty1 year5 years

DGE Series Propane Grill


Check on Amazon

Here are some pros and cons of the Dyna-Glo DGE Series 4-Burner Propane Grill.

  • 10,000 BTUs on each tube burner and 12,000 BTU on the side grill
  • 7-mm cooking grates and heat tents
  • Pull-out tray for tank storage with doors
  • Heat tents and double-wall construction improves, retains and distributes heat
  • Warming rack
  • Side tables do not fold down
  • More expensive than its Char-Broil counterpart
  • The support for warming rack gets rust

Performance 475


Check on Amazon

Take a look at the ups and downs of Char-Broil Performance 475 4-Burner grill.

  • More compact and saves storage space
  • With built-in swing-away rack
  • Porcelain-finish cast iron
  • Removable grease pan
  • Lower BTU
  • Smaller cooking area than the Dyna Glo grill

2. Dyna-Glo DGD381BNC-D vs. Char-Broil American Gourmet 300


For barbeque lovers who can’t enjoy the meat without that authentic grilled flavor and aroma, the charcoal grills are what they need. For this inclination, their choice would be the Dyna-Glo DGD381BNC-D Grill and the Char-Broil American Gourmet 300. Both grills have a compact, wheeled steel construction that lasts for many years. Their black exteriors add a contemporary touch to any patio or backyard.

But what makes them different? Let us start with the size of the grilling area. The Dyna-Glo DGS381BNC-D Compact Charcoal Grill has two cooking areas – the primary cooking burner measures 381 square inches while the second one is 165 square inches.

The porcelain-covered grates are made of cast iron that improves the heat transfer across the cooking surface. On the other hand, the Char-Broil American Gourmet has 225 square inches of cooking area. Its grates are also cast-iron similar to the Dyna-Glo’s.

Both grills have a built-in temperature gauge that allows you to monitor the cooking temperature. But when it comes to the coal grate height, the Char-Broil made it better. You can turn the cast-iron handle lower or higher depending on the food’s cooking requirements.

This mechanism makes it possible to move the burning coals or hot grates when you need to. You can also adjust the cooking temperature in the Dyna-Glo grill by lowering or raising the coal tray.

When it comes to convenience and ease of use, you will never go wrong with either of the two grills. They have a removable tray that collects the ash and grease. You can wipe the grates with a damp cloth. You don’t have to wipe them sparkling clean as the fire can kill the bacteria when you use the grates again.

 Dyna-Glo DGD381BNC-DChar-Broil American Gourmet 300
Cooking area381 square inches225 square inches
Grease panRemovableRemovable
Cooking gratesNot adjustableAdjustable
Weight77 pounds4 pounds

DGD381BNC-D Compact Charcoal Grill


Check on Amazon

Here’s a quick view of the Dyna-Glo DGD381BNC-D Compact Charcoal Grill’s advantages and disadvantages.

  • Larger cooking areas with a total of 545 square inches
  • Steel door for easy access to the coals
  • Adjustable flue to add or reduce taste or aroma
  • The height of the grate is not adjustable

American Gourmet 300 Series Grill


Check on Amazon

On the other hand, Char-Broil American Gourmet 300 Series Grill has its strong and weak points.

  • Flexible fire grates and coal tray
  • The fold-down shelf on the front and a side shelf
  • The manufacturer replaces defective parts
  • Does not let the smoke and heat out too much
  • The entire grill weighs 4 pounds only
  • The coal grate height is difficult to adjust

3. Dyna-Glo DGSS1382VCS-D vs. Char-Broil American Gourmet Offset Smoker Deluxe


If you prefer an offset smoker for ultimate smoky flavor and aroma, you can choose between the Dyna-Glo DGSS1382VCS-D Vertical Offset Charcoal Smoker & Grill and the Char-Broil Offset Smoker Deluxe.

Both grills have the cool-touch handles, wheeled frame for easy transport, all-black steel construction, and porcelain-finish grates. But they have a lot of differences such as the cooking area dimensions, numbers of grates, and other additional features.

If you are looking for a smoker that can cook large servings of meat at a time, the Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D vertical-standing smoker & grill is suitable for you. It has five chrome-plated grates that make up a total of 1382 square inches of cooking area.

It also comes with a sausage hook to expand the cooking area. This large capacity allows for more grilling and smoking flexibility and functionality. However, it may take up quite a big space in your backyard and more space for storage.

If you have a small patio, you can go use the Offset Smoker Deluxe from Char-Broil. It has a total dimension of 28.2 by 60.2 by 51 inches, but also with a much smaller cooking area of 290 square inches.

Nonetheless, the primary cooking area can accommodate up to 18 burgers. It has a warming rack where you can place the cooked meat and an adjustable chimney vent to control the smoke, two features that you can’t find in the Dyna-Glo grill.

When it comes to cleaning and maintenance, the Dyna-Glo smoker and grill made it better. The offset charcoal grate and ash pan are removable. It allows you to dispose of the ash and access the coals easily. The Char-Broil smoker only has the door for easy access to the ashtray. However, it has a front shelf for additional storage space, an advantage over the Dyna-Glo grill and smoker.

 Dyna-Glo DGSS1382VCS-DChar-Broil Offset Smoker Deluxe
Cooking area1382 square inches290 square inches
AshtrayNot removableRemovable
Cooking gratesAdjustableNot adjustable
WarrantyNot specified1 year
Weight124.3 pounds102.1 pounds

DGSS1382VCS-D Vertical Smoker & Grill


Check on Amazon

Get familiar with some bullet info on Dyna-Glo DGSS1382VCS-D Vertical Smoker & Grill if you like a quick summary.

  • Sausage hooks for flexible and added cooking space
  • Removable offset charcoal grate and ashtray
  • Easy-to-read analog temperature
  • Prolonged cooking for perfectly smoked barbeque
  • Extra-large wheels for convenient transport
  • Require more storage space
  • No warming rack or additional areas for storage

American Gourmet Offset Smoker Deluxe


Check on Amazon

The positives and negatives of Char-Broil Offset Smoker Deluxe are listed below.

  • The fire grate height is adjustable
  • Comes with a warming rack and storage rack
  • Adjustable dampers for heat and smoke control
  • More affordable than the Dyna-Glo grill and smoker
  • Can cook less meat at a time
  • Smaller wheels

The Final Say

If you want a compact grill and smoker, the Char-Broil products mentioned in this article are more suitable for you. It also comes with more additional features such as warming and storage shelves. These products are also less expensive than their Dyna-Glo counterparts. If you regularly prepare barbeque for a larger crowd, the Dyna-Glo grills are worth considering.

Regardless of the models that you choose, you will never go wrong when it comes to convenience. All products have safety handles and features for easy cleaning. They also have built-in wheels so you can carry them from the storage to your patio, back and forth. They are worth the investment and provides an enjoyable barbeque experience.

Leave a Comment

14 − eight =